This is a heartbreaking development in the ongoing crisis. The murder of Shiri Bibas while in Hamas captivity, along with her two young sons, is another tragic reminder of the brutality of the October 7 attacks. The fact that Hamas initially provided the body of a Palestinian woman instead of Bibas adds to the cruelty and manipulation surrounding hostage negotiations.
The Israeli government has been clear in its demands for the return of all hostages, both living and deceased. The ongoing ceasefire-hostage deal remains fragile, and it is uncertain whether the second phase—calling for the release of all remaining hostages in exchange for a permanent ceasefire—will move forward.
Hamas, designated as a terrorist organization by Israel, the U.S., the EU, and several other countries, has a long history of using hostages as bargaining chips. The group’s claim of a “mix-up” regarding Bibas’ body is met with skepticism, especially given the evidence that her sons were murdered in November 2023.
Meanwhile, as the first phase of the deal concludes, Hamas is expected to release four more bodies, and Israel will release 602 Palestinian prisoners. However, with 67 hostages still in Gaza, including at least 35 confirmed dead, the situation remains dire.
This tragedy further intensifies calls for international intervention and pressure on Hamas to fully comply with the agreement. The suffering of the Bibas family, like that of many others affected by the October 7 attacks, will not be forgotten.
